r/nottheonion • u/wewhomustnotbenamed • 7d ago
South Carolina Abortion Bill Would Impose Death Penalty For Terminating A Pregnancy
https://theblockcharlotte.com/1399970/south-carolina-abortion-bill-would-impose-death-penalty-for-terminating-a-pregnancy/6.9k
u/Specific_Rutabaga_87 7d ago
so pro life they'll kill for it.
838
u/Wrathb0ne 7d ago
“Pregnant but had a miscarriage previously? Believe it or not we’ll kill you and your unborn child”
→ More replies97
1.8k
u/beehaving 7d ago
Quite the oxymoron they have: we value life but only till you’re born then death by any means is acceptable
370
u/JeddakofThark 7d ago
The problem with children and adults is that they often have their own opinions. Opinions that might well conflict with conservative values. But fetuses? Those things are always white, conservative Christians.
→ More replies88
759
u/SomeWeirdoOnTheNet 7d ago
I believe the technical term is doublethink, coined by George Orwell in his novel, 1984.
217
u/GrimCreepaz 7d ago
George Carlin said “If you’re pre-born, you’re fine. If you’re preschool, you’re fucked.”
29
10
u/SnarfbObo 6d ago
This was clear to even him way back in the 90's and it wasn't new then either.
I feel it is important context to show how this is a longstanding and an ongoing problem.
I thank you for beating me to the quote, keep up the good work.
→ More replies467
u/CoffeeTeaBitch 7d ago
I hate how the right appropiated the novel's vocabulary when it is meant to criticize what they are doing. Hell, in the novel a major plot point is the state prohibiting passionate, pre-marital sex. While I admit it's not an exact analogy to what is happening today (in the novel, sex is prohibited as a way to redirect their passion towards Big Brother, while the purpose for banning abortion is pretty much sexism and perhaps for keeping poor people and minorities slaves), the novel is a warning against that kind of reach from the government. Not to mention the well known fact that Orwell was a socialist.
181
u/RJ815 7d ago
Many Republicans feel that government overreach is fine, so long as it's in their favor. It's always been hypocrisy.
→ More replies→ More replies354
u/SomeWeirdoOnTheNet 7d ago
I think it was best summed up by a post I saw a few years ago:
"1984 was a warning, not an instruction manual."
147
u/GarmonboziaBlues 7d ago
And the modern analog- "In the world of the Roberts court, The Handmaid's Tale is a documentary not a Hulu series."
→ More replies32
32
→ More replies90
u/TrashApocalypse 7d ago
They’re just showing the world how much they truly hate women. That women are mere objects to them, used for the sole purpose of making them children.
For anyone who doesn’t believe me, just follow r/arethestraightsok for a little while
→ More replies107
u/Id_Fuck_That_Dish 7d ago
I cherish peace with all my heart. I don’t care how many men, women, and children I need to kill to get it.
- Peacemaker
→ More replies99
u/livinginfutureworld 7d ago
“Pro-life conservatives are obsessed with the fetus from conception to 9 months. After that, they don’t wanna know about you. They don’t wanna hear from you. No nothing! No neonatal care, no daycare, no Head Start, no school lunch, no food stamps, no welfare, no nothing. If you’re pre-born, you’re fine, if you’re preschool, you’re fucked.”
-George Carlin, 1996
183
u/GallantChaos 7d ago
This isn't pro-life anymore. It's pro insanity.
→ More replies160
u/chaotic----neutral 7d ago
It's exactly what it has always been, pro forced birth. It is about punishment for decisions. Christians believe that sex for pleasure is a sin. They want to punish women who do it. They don't want to prevent abortions. They want to prevent sex.
Life was never sacred to them. It's a convenient excuse.
→ More replies→ More replies118
u/viciousrebel 7d ago
This was a really good George Carlin skit and republicans are proving him right with every year that passes by.
→ More replies52
u/Dangerousrhymes 7d ago
They continue to carry his legacy in the most depressing and ironic ways possible
2.7k
u/TheLadyKoi 7d ago
In some cases, the mother is charged with murder after having a legitimate miscarriage. It's only going to get worse from here.
940
u/PygmeePony 7d ago
Miscarriages happen all the time and can be very traumatic especially if it's late term because you're forced to give birth to a dead fetus. So instead of providing much needed support for the grieving parents the authorities give you a new trauma by charging you with murder?
455
u/OMGEntitlement 7d ago
If you're not rich or you're the wrong color or you disrespected a cop once or any number of other little petty shitty reasons, absolutely 100% yes yes yes.
98
u/hellfiredarkness 7d ago
I'm surprised they haven't just tried to have mandatory death penalty for all crimes at this point.....
→ More replies106
u/san_serifs 7d ago
Because Republican politicians would all be on death row.
85
u/aRandomFox-II 7d ago
They can simply exempt themselves, just as they have been doing for ages already.
→ More replies97
u/whereismymind86 7d ago
And by all the time, we mean ALL THE TIME, supposedly something to the tune of 25% of all pregnancy ends in miscarriage
→ More replies14
u/TheAskewOne 7d ago edited 6d ago
Miscarriages happen so much that over half (if I'm not mistaken) of fertilized eggs fail and are evacuated in the first few days, and women don't even realize it because their next period isn't late.
668
u/VoDoka 7d ago
I legitimately cannot imagine anyone in such a state making the informed decision to still have children.
641
u/killerbee2319 7d ago
Yeah, that's why they want to take away birth control.
→ More replies423
u/Realworld 7d ago edited 6d ago
The bill would also define a “person” as an “unborn child at every stage of development from fertilization until birth.”
Fertilization occurs in wide part (ampulla) of Fallopian tube. From there the fertilized ovum (zygote) is transported to uterus where new embryo is implanted in uterine wall 5-6 days later.
Combined oral contraceptives ("the pill") function through number of effects including suppressed ovulation, decreased sperm mobility, and diminished zygote transport. If fertilization occurs the zygote is unlikely to reach uterus while viable.
In other words, birth control pills can prevent embryo implant after fertilization. South Carolina women on the pill will statistically (and unknowingly) be committing murder under this law. I foresee birth control pills being outlawed in the future.
edit: sp
203
u/hour_of_the_rat 7d ago
I could see Red States enacting laws that grant personhood status & state residency to any visiting pregnant woman's fetus.
Example, a woman, who is recently pregnant, visits her family in Texas and then returns home. Upon learning she is pregnant, she goes to have an abortion.
The Texas state government, using Big Data, has tracked her while visiting the state, returning home, and visiting a Planned Parenthood Clinic. They are reasonably sure she has just committed 'murder' of one of their 'temporary residents' who they claim jurisdiction over. A arrest warrant is issued, and they request extradition.
→ More replies124
u/whereismymind86 7d ago
And the woman’s home state tells Texas police to shove that extradition order waaaayyyy up their asses
149
121
u/Radthereptile 7d ago
And she can never visit family in Texas again because she has an active warrant. And when she applies for a job her background check will come back as having an active warrant for murder. It impacts a lot.
→ More replies→ More replies26
u/FStubbs 7d ago
And Texas police (depending on how bold they are) go to her home state, arrest her, and take her back to Texas, and wait for the Supreme Court to rule in their favor.
18
u/BarnDoorHills 7d ago
That's ridiculous and would never... oh she's black? Yeah, it would happen. Might be bounty hunters though, rather than Texas police.
23
u/FStubbs 7d ago
It would be Texas police. They'd want the Supreme Court to rule that their police have jurisdiction in blue states to enforce Texas laws. They don't get that with bounty hunters.
→ More replies115
u/Pootins_Mini_PP 7d ago
In comparison: the magical idea that “human life begins at conception” was invented by Pope Pius IX in 1869, when Civil War medical practitioners were also barbers, and whisky was the only anesthetic.
Pius IX was a fascist, antisemitic, pro-slavery maniac. He kidnapped a young jewish boy as a child and kept him as his personal sex slave for life, and sided with the American Confederacy during our Civil War. He’s venerated as being nearly a saint by the Catholic Church.
→ More replies→ More replies12
109
u/emmainthealps 7d ago
Imagine you have a bunch of embryos in storage from doing ivf? Is it the death penalty if you have them destroyed because you don’t want more children? Or do you have to transfer them all
→ More replies101
u/whereismymind86 7d ago
Yes, this has come up before, these people also want to criminalize ivf
→ More replies43
u/Shitty_UnidanX 7d ago
My parents had fertility issues so I was born via IVF. My life would be a crime.
→ More replies84
→ More replies31
u/kobushi5 7d ago
I could not imagine not trying to leave asap
→ More replies36
u/Lmb1011 7d ago
I want to leave the entire damn country but it’s so hard to do. In the meantime I’m Lowkey hoping I just get menopause in my 30s so I can be past the fear of pregnancy killing me in one capacity of another
→ More replies105
u/Helenium_autumnale 7d ago
How can they do that when women can't control miscarriages? Make this insanity stop.
→ More replies108
u/Paksarra 7d ago
Find anything they can blame you for. Drink coffee? Work a stressful job? Quit your stressful job and got stressed out by finances? Didn't go to church twice a week to pray for your child's health? Live in a city with higher levels of air pollution?
You should have known better.
→ More replies64
u/MC_Fap_Commander 7d ago
Absolutely no woman who is pregnant or possibly pregnant should be visiting these anti-choice states.
A miscarriage and the wrong judge could lead to irreparable harm. These places deserve to be ostracized like "South Africa during Apartheid."
→ More replies→ More replies56
u/HairyPossibility676 7d ago
There was an article just this week about a hospital in rural Idaho closing its obstetrics services because they’d lost all their doctors due to the harsh abortion laws in that state. Doctors don’t want to be forced into providing sub par standard of care because of these backwards laws. Now an entire community will have to drive 46 miles if they need an OB. I wonder if we will see more of that as these laws keep getting more and more ridiculous
→ More replies31
1.1k
u/kristamine14 7d ago
Remember like 5 years ago when Americans were saying abortion was an enshrined right and couldn’t be taken away - and now you’re already at death penalty for women who get abortions… it’s be funny if it wasn’t so evil
378
u/Four-Name-Girl 7d ago
Canadian here. We keep being told that our rights are safe and that we shouldn't just vote based on abortion access, but fuck that, this shit is scary. It's easy for some to say "relax, what about the economy?" As if bodily autonomy wasn't the most important thing.
158
u/mybustlinghedgerow 7d ago
God, I remember being told that women’s rights and the fight to protect bodily autonomy were “side-issues” meant to distract from the only real issue, which is the economy. So stupid.
62
u/Dave-4544 6d ago
I remember being told "women's rights" were a done deal after the Suffragate and Women's Right To Vote movements. Jesus christ what a fuckin' world.
Black Civil Rights (and the other less talked about issues like Indigenous People's Rights) were also treated as solved issues in the history books. I genuinely believed we were living in a better world for all. I'll never be able to live in that bubble of happy social ignorance again, but I sure as hell am glad that it was burst. People need help, protection, and allies now more than ever. However there's only so much one person with no influence can do aside from cast votes and be kind..
Hang in there everyone.
→ More replies17
u/illgot 7d ago
America is what happens when you are legally allowed to bribe politicians and give corporations everything they want.
Don't be like America.
→ More replies75
u/TheSquishiestMitten 7d ago
Well, Brett Kavanaugh specifically said that Roe v Wade was settled during his confirmation hearing to SCOTUS. The fact that Roe v Wade is no longer means that Kavanaugh lied during his hearing. He should be removed from the bench and imprisoned for lying under oath. I mean, he lied about a bunch of other stuff, too.
→ More replies164
u/pecklepuff 7d ago
So many people skipped voting for years and years because they were so cock-sure that our rights were rock solid and they didn’t need to defend them.
FAFO.
→ More replies→ More replies54
u/TiredMontanan 7d ago
Remember less than a year ago Republicans said this was about letting states decide, and not about restricting access? Vote. Run for office. Get involved. We can still turn this thing around. I hope.
→ More replies
891
860
u/BrazenDropout 7d ago
How is this not about control of women
261
→ More replies31
u/gra_mor 7d ago
No no you misunderstand. Its about dehumanising women and then making them property. That's totally different.
→ More replies
457
u/westdl 7d ago
Consider being a doctor or nurse in maternity. Do you want to risk going to work if it means a premature birth could mean you, your coworkers and your patient will be executed?
→ More replies263
u/kazooparade 7d ago
OBs have the means and motivation to leave shitty anti-women states where they are not allowed to provide good care. In fact many already are. Unfortunately that means less available/worse care for the women that live in those areas. This will disproportionately affect poor women.
→ More replies138
u/AmumuPro 7d ago
Meanwhile rich people or Republicans can go to a state that have full access to abortion to get their abortion
→ More replies
1.0k
u/escape1979uk 7d ago
"Pro-Life" - What a fucking circus..
60
112
u/thoroakenfelder 7d ago
It's almost like life is not as sacred as they keep saying and it's just a wedge issue to make ignorant people vote against their own interests. But, I'm just an old country rooster and not a lawyer, so maybe I don't understand the big words.
→ More replies63
246
u/bigbangbilly 7d ago
A bunch of people with life threatening pregnancy and nothing to lose seem like a potential recipe for disaster
→ More replies
351
u/a_seventh_knot 7d ago
these fucking idiots are never satisfied.
→ More replies175
u/yunabladez 7d ago
Blood for the blood god
Skulls for the skull throne
121
u/scipio0421 7d ago
Don't compare Chaos to these guys. One is a group of morally depraved assholes who would wantonly kill anyone they thought they could get away with and who have no souls. The other opposes the Imperium of Man.
27
231
u/midnightwomble 7d ago
you cant be serious. I am so pro life I will kill you. Should be put in a padded cell for your own protection coming up with this shit
→ More replies36
u/blackscales18 7d ago
The point is creating more white babies at any cost, and oppressing women back into the home
110
87
71
u/Ljhoyt77 7d ago
Republicans are fucking going crazy. Can we just agree to abort them.
28
u/TiredMontanan 7d ago
This is what happens when half of a political monopoly doesn’t have any actual ideas. They run a culture war to make people scared and angry:
“They’re coming to abort your kids and teach CRT in schools! We’re so busy with these pressing issues that we don’t have time to talk about how Republicans would solve automation, housing, environmental collapse, or crumbling infrastructure! CRT!!!”
→ More replies
139
u/Educational_Hawk1029 7d ago
I feel like we should be able to vote these idiots (politicians) off the island. According to National Geographic…
“In ancient Athens, ostracism was the process by which any citizen, including political leaders, could be expelled from the city-state for 10 years.
Once a year, ancient Athenian citizens would nominate people they felt threatened democracy—because of political differences, dishonesty, or just general dislike. Today, although we can vote politicians out of office, we can’t exactly banish them from politics for a decade.”
I say we return to the old ways. Seemed to work for them. /s
→ More replies74
u/Masque-Obscura-Photo 7d ago
Vote? I'm looking on from Europe and am seriously baffled how you are not up in arms against these literal nazis.
41
u/ScarofReality 7d ago
Not much we can do here when the police usually side with the Nazis.
→ More replies→ More replies29
71
u/supernovababoon 7d ago
You really can’t make this shit up. The cognitive dissonance is absurd. Republicans want to protect life so badly they want to kill people. Yet they don’t support healthcare and services for those that are alive. And they are also worried about too many minorities eroding white political power yet banning abortion disproportionately affects minorities which will only strengthen this demographic shift long-term. It really is unbelievable.
→ More replies
136
u/Twilightalpha 7d ago
Let me get this straight... Their anti abortion concept (which the law is based on) is to save unborn children (lives) and to ensure it's enforced they're going to kill mothers who violate it??
Evel Knievel couldn't make that jump!
→ More replies16
461
u/Olympus___Mons 7d ago
So if a pregnant woman is assaulted and her unborn baby is killed, should the attacker be charged with murder of the unborn child?
238
u/theLonelyBinary 7d ago
I was a victim of a crime and the woman with me was pregnant, the person got attempted murder and assault charges for both of us plus the unborn child.
212
107
→ More replies75
u/lastprophecy 7d ago
No, that's the woman's fault for leaving the house without a male escort.
→ More replies
179
288
u/Rustys_Shackleford 7d ago
I have one child, and have been thinking about having another. I live in South Carolina. I’m going to call my doctor on Monday to discuss getting my tubes tied. It’s not worth it.
184
→ More replies58
u/putmeinabag 7d ago
Please look into a bilateral salpingectomy. It is the complete removal of the Fallopian tubes as opposed to tying them. Good luck.
→ More replies
95
u/Uncle_Bug_Music 7d ago
Pretty soon attempted suicide in some states will result in the death penalty.
→ More replies
153
u/Awkward_Village_6871 7d ago
Ahh, the good old times where men dictate how women are things.
→ More replies
40
39
u/Automatic-Salad-931 7d ago
How about the death penalty for child molesters and rapists? Priorities people.
→ More replies
391
u/nexusgmail 7d ago
Not Oniony at all, sadly. America is quickly becoming a dystopian nightmare.
150
u/harbinger_nz 7d ago
I prefer the term "Taliban state", given the hate towards women these obscene laws are designed show
44
20
u/frofya 7d ago
I hate blaming the Taliban (shitty though they are) for this. Let’s call it what it really is: Evangelical Christian extremism. Calling it a “Taliban state” kind of makes it seem “other”, kind of makes it seem like it was imported to us when it’s not. This is ideology is American born & bred. We allowed it to happen. We’re to blame.
→ More replies74
39
u/Wazza17 7d ago
Those who support and vote for these laws should face the same penalty
→ More replies
120
u/Right-Fisherman-1234 7d ago
They do know that a woman can still have more kids later even if she's had an abortion, right? RIGHT???? SMFH!
118
→ More replies52
u/tiptherobots 7d ago
In that part of the world, the nice White lady would probably get a slap on the wrist, and be encouraged to change her ways and procreate. Anyone else; dead woman walking.
→ More replies
31
29
87
u/couchtomato62 7d ago
Thank goodness in 1958 my mom left that god forsaken state and moved to california.
85
u/MakoSanchez 7d ago
So this is what MAGA means by great AGAIN?? Back to...what? No womens rights, segregation ...hey why not slavery?? Let's try all the things that were horrible. That's a fun idea. Wtfih is happening right now
59
→ More replies25
56
58
u/kro9ik 7d ago
I simply do not understand this unhealthy fascination of Americans with abortion. It's a medical procedure that a woman undergoes after making a choice. Most countries do continue to control some aspect of it but not to the act of banning it or even criminalising it.
49
7d ago
[deleted]
13
u/Laringar 7d ago
If the fetus dies in utero, the procedure to remove it is still an abortion. As such, I know someone who had an abortion at 39 weeks.
There should be no limit on when an abortion can occur, because otherwise pregnant women will have their health put at risk.
→ More replies19
u/QuietRock 7d ago
First off, it's not all Americans who are obsessed with abortion, it's a specific segment of Americans, specifically right-wing Christians.
I believe reason is not as straightforward as you may believe. They use the moral front and emotional appeal of "killing babies" to rile up supporters, but that is not their motivation behind the desire to eliminate abortion.
It is really about maintaining control over women, which starts but does not end with abortion. Birth control is already up next. This will help "keep women in their place" and roll back women's liberalism. After all, the pill and abortion changed sexual power dynamics, and was closely linked to the beginning of women's lib.
→ More replies40
u/APlayerHater 7d ago
Birth rate is dropping and our corporate masters can't have that.
→ More replies24
u/pecklepuff 7d ago edited 7d ago
We could go the way of Poland and Japan where women’s access to abortion is restricted, so lots of women just stopped having sex and relationships with men. It just accelerates the decline in birth rates, and rightfully so.
→ More replies
27
u/BiffBanter 7d ago
"eligible for the death penalty."
They want to define it as murder, so the same as if someone killed a born person.
→ More replies
30
u/Charming_Computer_60 7d ago
Hypocrites. They claim that all life is sacred yet they want death to a woman who had an abortion? What does that solve? Nothing at all.
→ More replies
26
u/QuickLime89 7d ago
This is some Salem Witch Trials shit over there.
"The doctor has deemed that bringing this baby to term will near certainly end your life. Therefore we will give you one final test. If you choose to terminate this pregnancy, you will be deemed a witch and we will burn you at the stake. If you don't terminate this pregnancy, you will be deemed pure as you allow your baby to kill you from the inside. Praise be to God."
64
23
u/Beaglerampage 7d ago
And try to prove that miscarriage wasn’t an abortion. The USA has gone crazy! The handmaiden’s tail is here.
19
u/MegaAscension 7d ago
People who rag on Alabama don’t realize that South Carolina is more backwards than Alabama. My boyfriend and I are afraid to do any PDA because we think we might get attacked or shot. And this is in one of the bluest parts of the state too.
→ More replies
52
u/herbys 7d ago
If you are pregnant with twins, and one of the fetuses causes the other to stop developing, does this bill say you have to abort the remaining baby?
→ More replies
17
u/thisoldmould 7d ago
Welcome to Gilead folks.
This is what happens when you don’t actively participate in democracy. Your freedom and justice is taken from you.
→ More replies
15
u/I_Dont_Have_Corona 7d ago
Executing women for choices for what should be their rights. Is this America or the Middle East?
13
u/HairTop23 7d ago
This is disgusting. Shame on every single republican who continues to support the party
60
u/wewhomustnotbenamed 7d ago
South Carolina must learn of our pro-life ways... BY FORCE!
→ More replies43
12
13
12
u/foodiefuk 7d ago
Just banning abortion will kill many women via complicated pregnancies and domestic abuse. This is just an excuse to murder liberal doctors too. Modern conservativism is just a death cult run by billionaire elites.
26
u/jrochest1 7d ago
Why don't they just cut out the middle term and just kill all the women in the state? That seems to be their objective in the long run.
→ More replies
12
u/Familiar_Pea_9345 7d ago
Laws like this have no place in a civilized society. Conservatives don’t give a damn if society regresses as long as they get their money and power over the rest of us. I hope they all get the guillotine before that happens.
10
u/Sleepdprived 7d ago
This law is for virtue signaling that "We are more holy than thou" and that game never ends. It goes from abortion and same sex couples to contraceptives, to pornography and alchohol, and it ends with "you know we are the holy chosen people we should control all of God's holy land" they want to make America a Christian nation and then the next stop is a HOLY WAR. It might be another crusade, it might be a type of "missionary " but it will end in blood because the "I'm more virtuous" game ends in holy wars.
→ More replies
57
u/JWBIERE 7d ago
Aren't the male Republican politicians in South Carolina killing millions of potential babies when they jerk off to gay and trans porn?
→ More replies
10
5.7k
u/orient_vermillion 7d ago
Wait.... so, people who commit murder get jail sentence but women who choose to abort get death sentence? Wtf?!